Special Council Meeting speech (City Plan Part 2) - Labour and the Greens betray their constituents while Conservatives fight to save urban fringe

The Conservatives are taking a strong stand tonight to save 16 urban fringe green sites,  listed in this City Plan,  from development. 
 
We want to see the removal of section H2 in its entirety, and new housing considered only on brownfield sites. 
 
This shouldn’t be a big ask or a problem. 
 
According to Labour’s own figures, Brownfield housing accounts for 90% of the new housing in this City Plan. 
 
This would easily meet Brighton & Hove’s housing targets over the next 10 years without any need to build on precious green land in the urban fringe. 
 
And yet we find ourselves in a situation tonight where Labour and the Greens are joining forces and digging in – refusing to compromise, refusing to listen to the valid concerns of residents and environmental groups, and stubbornly demanding that we agree to build on 28 hectares of land, with high ecological value in our City – when there  is   no  need. 
 
So today I’m going to speak for residents and environmental groups across the City that are being ignored by Labour and Green representatives that have stopped listening to them. 
 
Whitehawk Hill is a special part of Brighton & Hove that sits within the Labour Leader’s own ward of East Brighton  - a ward represented by 3 labour councillors.  It is one of the16 green sites under threat in this City Plan. 
 
A publicly-available statement on the Friends of Whitehawk Hill Facebook page advises that more than half of the Labour Party branches in the City have passed motions demanding that Whitehawk Hill be removed from the City Plan and that this has been communicated to the Labour Leader Nancy Platt with a request that all Labour Party Councillors are made aware of it 
 
Despite this the Labour group still plans to vote to build on Whitehawk Hill against the wishes of its members and branches and I find myself in a position where I have to stand up for the residents in the Leader of the Council’s own ward of East Brighton because the Council Leader won’t listen. 
 
And it gets worse Madam Mayor. 
 
This City plan would also develop Ingleside stables which is completely surrounded by the South Downs National Park and sits within Moulsecomb & Bevendean Ward, another ward represented by 3 labour councillors  
 
But Madam Mayor perhaps the greatest betrayal of voters is in Brighton Pavilion constituency where 4 sites including Horsdean and Coldean are stated to be developed in this city plan. 
 
Just two days ago the Green MP for Brighton Pavilion Caroline Lucas took to twitter to praise Green Councillors in Lancashire for saving green space.   But as Green councillors here are about to vote to allow building on green spaces in her constituency she has remained absolutely silent.    It is stunning hypocrisy from the MP and it is for her to explain why she gets involved in supporting saving green land in Lancashire but not in her own seat. 
 
Madam Mayor it’s clear that Labour and the Greens are not listening to the people who elected them. 
 
But, there is a better way forward here which they should consider carefully and could still agree to. 
 
The Conservatives are saying we will support the brownfield development which represents 90% of this plan and meets Brighton & Hove’s housing targets – but not the 10% on green land in the urban fringe. 
 
So for Labour tonight there is a choice:   
 
You could have 90% of your City Plan agreed tonight, backed by all 3 parties, meet your housing targets, and at the same time protect the environment. 
 
Or you can be stubborn, stick to your position, betray your constituents and destroy 16 green sites forever with a cost to future generations. 
 
If you choose the latter, you’ll be judged very harshly by this City and the communities you represent. 
 
Thank you. Madam Mayor